Annotated Bibliography Assignment
“Journalists have been
shaping the language, thoughts and politics of the world at large” (Niblock, S.,
1996). Through communicating messages
and information to the public, journalists and reporters are able to mould the
perceptions and views on certain issues globally. This report will focus on the
recent news story of President Barack Obama supporting gay marriage and will be
analysed through the news sites of: The Sydney Morning Herald, CNN Politics and
ABC Radio National. The mediums that have been chosen are: a news article, a
television report and a radio interview. Each media forum provided similar
perspectives on the situation yet presented the findings in contrasting ways to
gain audience interest and provide a sense of credibility for each news
station. Along with the three texts covering the news story, an academic book
on the subject of Professional Communication and Journalism will also be
critically evaluated.
Niblock, S. (1996). Inside journalism. London: Blueprint.
Sarah Niblock, the
author of Inside Journalism, is a
journalist and writer whose scholarly research covers the discourses associated
with journalism studies, media and cultural studies, visual culture and
communication technologies. Her extended studies in Liverpool, including
freelancing news for the national press and writing regular features for
Cosmopolitan and Company magazines, prove her credibility in regards to the
literature world (Brunel University, 2011). The book exposes the internal
workings of the field of journalism and how the industry operates through
covering traditional press and magazines to radio and television shows. Niblock
also focuses on future technological changes that journalists must deal with in
order to continue to communicate effectively to the public whilst maintaining
an understanding of these transformations (Niblock, 1996). The book is
dissected into the concepts that a journalist must acquire in order to become
successful in achieving the most newsworthy story. Niblock discusses the
intricacies surrounding what makes a good story and the entertainment value
involved with each event that is presented to the public. However, not all emphasis
is placed on just the news story projected but the preparation that the
journalist must go through in order to completely understand the story and how
it will be received by the audience (Niblock, 1996). Multiple diagrams and
examples are provided throughout the book to add credibility to the piece along
with bolded headings for easier reading. The ideas and cases provided in
Niblock’s book addresses the key factors of successful journalism and what has
to be done in order to obtain a newsworthy story.
The Sydney Morning Herald released a comprehensive
news article on the recent support president Barack Obama declared in regards
to the controversial issue of gay marriage, marking an end to the prolonged
dispute (“Evolved” Obama backs
gay marriage, 2012). The article delves into the reasons
behind Obama’s decision and how the new position realigns himself with the
growing number of Democratic officials who have embraced full marriage rights
for gay and lesbian couples. Opinions and responses to this announcement were
also included to provide an overall understanding of the impact that Obama has
created not only to Americans, but to people around the globe (“Evolved” Obama backs gay marriage, 2012).
The number of timelines, images, statistics and quotes that are provided throughout
the article prove the extensive research that has taken place for the news
piece to be created, hence verifying its credibility. When comparing the Sydney
Morning Herald’s pieces with the style and approach of CNN, the contrasts are
extreme. Due to CNN being globally recognised and widespread with its
information and coverage of world news, it is a more commercial medium compared
to the localised Sydney newspaper (Gast, 2012). As CNN broadcasts to over 212
countries, the news broadcasted is trusted by the public as a reliable news
source and therefore, more people would be inclined to watch the report than
read the local newspaper.
Gast, P. (Writer). (2012, May 9). Obama: Gay marriage “should be legal”
[Television broadcast]. Washington,
D.C.: CNN
The CNN Politics television report provided the
speech that Barack Obama recently gave to ABC about his beliefs on equality for
gays and lesbians and the reasoning behind his initial hesitation to support
gay marriage (Gast, 2012). He further explains the importance that is put upon
the word “marriage” for all communities around the world and that people still
feel constrained within their own rights to marry who they please. He ends with
the line: “For me, I believe same-sex couples should be able to marry”
affirming his previous outlook on the matter and solidifying the views he
supports for the future (Gast, 2012). In terms of credibility, due to CNN
utilising the coverage of the Obama interview from ABC, another reliable and
widely known news station, the report is proven to be trustworthy and impartial.
The footage is maintained in the exact same format and presented in a formal
and professional manner. CNN and ABC are similar in their news broadcasting
styles due to their global representations that must be upheld to gain public
interest and importance (Kelly, 2012). Both
stations have a commercial edge to their broadcasting. In this circumstance,
the fact that ABC reported this new report first, proves that ABC was more up
to date and current than CNN.
Kelly, F. (Writer). (2012). Obama supports same-sex marriage [Radio program]. Washington, D.C.:
ABC Radio National
ABC Radio National publicly
announces that Barack Obama is the first US president to openly support
same-sex marriage. It is explained that he finally made his position clear a
day after voters in North Carolina approved a state constitutional amendment
forbidding gay marriages, civil unions and domestic partnerships (Kelly, 2012).
An interview is also conducted with David Mark, a Senior White House writer
with politico.com and he speaks from Washington DC on why he believes Obama has
chosen now to announce his support for gay marriages. The interview provides an
insight into the dealings with marriage and what effect Obama’s declaration
will have for Americans and people around the world (Kelly, 2012). The previous
interview from Obama that was recorded by ABC was played at the beginning of
the radio show followed by the interview from David Mark. This order of events
displays the credibility of ABC Radio National as the speech from the president
is supported and explained by a credible politician afterwards. The interview
proves further research and clarifications of the reasoning behind Obama’s
decision. The comparisons between ABC and The Sydney Morning Herald are quite
extensive as once again, ABC are a widely known and global form of news whilst
the SMH relies purely on local opinion and audiences (“Evolved” Obama backs gay marriage, 2012). With ABC
broadcasting around the world, it proves to be a more reliable and trusted
source. The locally reported news usually gathers information and statistics
from national news programs such as the ABC, in order to present trustworthy material.
It is observed through
the three separate mediums of a news article, television report and radio show,
that the event of Barack Obama announcing his support for gay marriage can be
presented differently. Although each source may have its own expression upon
the matter and report in a slightly altered manner, The Sydney Morning Herald,
CNN and ABC all uphold their credibility as reliable and trustworthy news forums.
Although two of the news stations may be recognised internationally and the
other directed at local audiences, all news sources follow the practices of
good journalism (as outlined by Sarah Niblock’s book) and provide a newsworthy
piece.